Jaguar Clubs of North AmericaJCNA Home
Living with the X-Type : Postscript
by Daniel Thompson

Home  
News Archive Index

 

In December 0f 2001 I purchased a 2002 Jaguar X-type 2.5 liter with 5 speed manual transmission. A diary of my purchase experience can be found right here on the JCNA site.

10k miles punch list....

- both driver and passenger doors would not open from the outside. When you press on the remote you can hear the "clunk-clunk" as the door unlocks, but pulling on the exterior door handle has no effect. My solution has been to pound on the door handle with my palm, but even this is not working any more. It has now gotten to the point where the inside door pull will not open the door either. Rather embarrassing to say the least, especially if I have one of my clients waiting patiently for me to let him into the car. The dealer says the problem is common, requiring about an hour of adjustingcables inside the doors to rectify.

- I have a rotational, fairly loud "squeak-squeak-squeak" from the front of the car, most noticeable at low speed with the windows down (of course). This started after I thrashed the car around Lime Rock Racepark for a weekend and I suspect it is front wheel bearing(s).

- the little light on the dash above the glovebox that illustrates a person sitting in front of an airbag comes on when the car is started and stays on. It is supposed to indicate an airbag malfunction so I guess it should be rectified! I noticed just last night as a passenger got out of my car while stopped at a traffic light that the little light came on again and then turned off after a few seconds. Not really sure what this means but it sounds like an electrical mix up.

- Yesterday I stopped to get gas on the way home from a 300 mile business trip and the fuel door lever pulled up with no resistance. Oh-oh! Sure enough, no amount of playing with the lever would get the fuel filler door to open. Even banging on it with my flat palm did no good. Very interesting! Since I was by myself I could not get someone else to hold the lever in the up position whilst I banged away (very embarrassing to ask a stranger to do this, especially on a new Jaguar...). Finally I took the owners manual (so that's what it's for...) and stuck it under the lever to hold it in the up position and then used a credit card to pry open the fuel filler door. Worked like a charm! It appears to be working fine again but what would have happened if I was a mechanically challenged Jaguar owner.

- I have asked to have the oil change done with synthetic oil. I was told by the service manager that regular oil is standard, synthetic will be charged to the customer. Then the nice lady that books appointments told me that synthetic was standard issue for oil changes..... We shall see.

Final complaint would be the clutch action; not whimpy. Many journalists have complained about this. I assume Jaguar simply tried to make the action too fluid or light or whatever and the result is a limp, vague clutch action that never seems to catch in the same place twice. It is still easy to stall this car when moving off from rest. Of course, I have gotten used to it now and my solution is (naturally) to slip the clutch.

I have now lived with my X-type for ten months and 10,000 miles (16,000 kilometers). I can honestly say that the car has been simplymarvelous. It is smooth, quiet, comfortable, fast, fun and elegant. Average fuel consumption has been about 23 mpg (Imperial) but I attribute much of this to the way I drive (fast). When I took my car in for its first major service, I noted the following items requiring attention ( see sidebar )

The car spent the day at the dealer on October 15th and came back better than ever. The door problem was fixed by adjusting the cables and latching mechanism, the fuel door was lubricated and works fine. The squeak turned out to be glazed brake pads, a result of my overheating the brakes while turning laps at Lime Rock race Race Park last May. The pads were "decontaminated" and the discs cleaned and now the car is quiet again and brakes smoothly. Pad wear is only 20% front and rear after 10,000 miles. Pretty good considering the way I brake. Tire wear has also been impressive.

To solve the oil mystery, my service manager confirmed to me that regular oil is standard issue for this model. I asked for and received synthetic oil at my cost. The mysterious air bag light that would not turn off has been solved; it was my fault! I have a habit of leaving my heavy briefcase sitting on the passenger seat while driving. Sensors pick this up and think that someone, perhaps a lightweight child is sitting in the passenger seat and the light comes on as a warning. Problem solved, place briefcase on floor!

There are NO other issues with the car with the exception of the clutch. The oil change and switch to synthetic did the car a world of good; in my experience all cars seem to "sing" a happy tune right after you change their oil. My X-type is no exception, all the imaginary noises I was hearing have disappeared and the car runs strong and quiet.

The clutch problem is more a personal thing than anything else. After years of driving cars like my E-type, I have gotten to like a firm clutch pedal with a very abrupt, positive action. The clutch in my X-type drives me a bit crazy with its lightness and vague action but I'll just have to learn to live with it.

Re-reading my comments made when the car was new, I don't think I would change a thing. The car still meets or exceeds all expectations. The 2.5 with the manual transmission is a fun car and can be a fast car. It is impressive on the highway if you learn to use the gearbox properly. It was very impressive on the race track due to its predictable handling, all wheel drive, great braking and steering. The engine can be made to "sing" in the 5,000 to 7,000 rpm range. And yes, the rev limiter will come in at about 7,200 rpm and shut down the engine! For those of you contemplating an automatic X-type, I would personally recommend the 3.0 liter version. You will not win any stop light Grand Prix with the 2.5 liter X-type, and from zero to thirty miles per hour just about any econobox will eat it alive. Stir the gearbox to 5,000 rpm in second and third gears though, and you will effortlessly sweep by slower cars.

The car, being recognized as a Jaguar, suffers from unwanted attention. I still get constantly harassed by drivers of German machinery, who all seem to want to race with me in the 80-100 m.p.h. range. I worry constantly about theft and vandalism, although so far I have only suffered the theft of the leaping cat hood ornament. Total cost for my first visit to the dealer was about $25 (the cost of the synthetic oil). Total operating costs in the first 10,000 miles are two unscheduled oil changes (before and after the track days), a new hood ornament at $175, and gas. The dealer has been absolutely first class: knowledgeable, timely and helpful on all counts.

Count me as one very satisfied customer!

 

 


On track at Limerock for the Empire Division Annual Driving School

Discuss the content of this article in the Current Production forum.

posted 10/16/2002

  LEGAL NOTICES

REPORT PROBLEM WITH THIS PAGE

© 2002 JAGUAR CLUBS OF NORTH AMERICA, INC.